6 Hot Takes from NRF 2026
What every independent retailer needs to know to compete with category killers in 2026
I just spent three days at the National Retail Federation's Big Show in New York City alongside 40,000 retail professionals, and the conversations happening there are going to reshape how independent brick-and-mortar stores compete against category killers in 2026. While the headlines focused on AI and technology, the real story was simpler: the retailers winning today are the ones using digital tools to amplify their physical stores—not replace them.
1 Your Physical Store is Your Competitive Advantage (Finally)
The biggest validation at NRF wasn't about technology—it was about physical retail being back in a big way. According to research presented at the conference, 61% of Gen Z consumers prefer to discover products in-store, not online.
Dick's Sporting Goods Executive Chairman Ed Stack shared how the company is doubling down on physical retail with their "House of Sport" concept—immersive stores where customers can try products on live fields and courts. Stack explained that they designed these stores to be so compelling that they would "put our traditional stores out of business."
Key Insight
The big-box retailers are finally admitting that physical retail is the future. They're investing millions to create experiences that independent retailers like you have been delivering for decades—personal service, local expertise, and community connection.
What this means for independent retailers:
Your store isn't a liability competing against online—it's your biggest asset. The question is: are you using your digital presence (Shopify, social media, Google) to drive more foot traffic?
Action Steps:
- Use your Shopify store to showcase what makes your physical location special (local events, expert staff, in-store experiences)
- Implement "buy online, pick up in store" to drive foot traffic
- Use Google My Business and local SEO to capture "near me" searches
- Share in-store experiences on social media to build FOMO
2 Shopify + Google Just Made It Easier to Sell Everywhere (Including AI Agents)
Shopify and Google dropped a bombshell at NRF: the Universal Commerce Protocol (UCP)—an open standard that allows any merchant to sell through AI agents, chatbots, and conversational commerce platforms.
What does this mean in plain English? When someone asks ChatGPT, Google Gemini, or any AI assistant "find me running shoes in my size," your products can show up—and they can buy directly through the AI conversation. No need to visit your website or a marketplace.
The Opportunity
Shopify merchants on the platform can now opt into this with their "Agentic plan," meaning your inventory, pricing, and checkout can be accessed by AI shopping agents across Google, potentially other platforms, and any future AI commerce channels.
What this means for independent retailers:
The way customers discover and buy products is changing fast. AI agents are becoming the new "storefront." If you're on Shopify, you're already positioned to take advantage of this—but you need to ensure your product data is clean and accurate.
Action Steps:
- Ensure your Shopify product data is complete (titles, descriptions, images, variants, inventory)
- Explore Shopify's Agentic plan options to enable AI agent commerce
- Think about how customers might describe your products conversationally (not just keyword search)
- Monitor how AI shopping evolves—this is the next frontier after Google Shopping
3 AI Can Free Your Team to Do What They Do Best: Sell
Every major retailer at NRF emphasized the same message: AI is a tool to empower employees, not replace them.
7-Eleven shared that by implementing conversational AI chatbots to support job applicants, they saved corporate store leaders an average of 2 million hours per year. That's time that can now be spent with customers, improving operations, and driving sales.
Sprouts Farmers Market discussed how they've gamified employee training with AI-powered content—making learning faster and more engaging while giving staff more time on the store floor with customers.
The Theme
Use AI to handle repetitive tasks so your team can focus on what independent retailers do better than anyone—building relationships and providing expert guidance.
What this means for independent retailers:
You don't need a massive tech budget. Simple AI tools can handle FAQs, appointment scheduling, inventory questions, and order tracking—freeing your team to focus on in-store customers.
Action Steps:
- Implement AI-powered chatbots on your Shopify store for basic questions (store hours, product availability, order status)
- Use automated email/SMS for order updates and appointment reminders
- Let your team focus on high-value activities: closing sales, building relationships, and providing expert advice
4 Google is Changing How Customers Discover Your Products
Google CEO Sundar Pichai announced Gemini Enterprise for Customer Experience—a platform that allows consumers to search for products, compare prices, read reviews, and see availability—all without leaving Google.
Walmart and Kroger have already signed on. Soon, when someone searches "best running shoes near me" or "Nike Air Max in stock," Google will show them a complete shopping experience with product options, pricing, store locations, and reviews.
The Challenge
If your product data isn't clean and your Google Business Profile isn't optimized, you won't show up when local customers are searching. The big-box retailers are investing heavily in this—you need to compete.
What this means for independent retailers:
Your visibility in local search is now more critical than ever. Clean product data and an optimized Google presence are no longer optional—they're essential to staying competitive.
Action Steps:
- Claim and optimize your Google Business Profile (photos, hours, inventory updates)
- Connect your Shopify store to Google Merchant Center (enable local inventory ads)
- Ensure your product data is accurate and includes local availability
- Encourage customers to leave Google reviews (this impacts local search ranking)
5 You Can't Out-Select or Out-Price Category Killers—So Don't Try
One of the most important conversations at NRF was about how traditional retailers are losing to category killers by trying to compete on selection and price across their entire product assortment.
The winning strategy, according to retail pricing experts at the conference, is to surgically identify the items you absolutely must be competitive on (hero products that customers price-compare), and own your differentiation everywhere else.
The Reality
You'll never have the selection of a Dick's Sporting Goods or the pricing power of a Best Buy. But you don't need to. You have something they don't: local expertise, personalized service, and community trust.
What this means for independent retailers:
Compete on the products that matter (top 10-20 SKUs that customers actively compare), and differentiate everywhere else with service, expertise, and experience.
Action Steps:
- Identify your top 10-20 products that customers price-compare (usually popular brands like Nike, Apple, etc.)
- Ensure you're competitive on those specific items
- For the rest of your catalog, compete on expertise, service, and experience—not price
- Use your Shopify store to tell your brand story and highlight what makes you different
6 Omnichannel Isn't Optional—But It Needs to Be Simple
Giant Eagle and Instacart discussed how omnichannel retail has shifted from "nice-to-have" to "must-have." But here's the critical insight: execution matters more than features.
Giant Eagle shared a candid lesson about their Scan-and-Go mobile app. The feature didn't land as expected because customers don't want to live in one app while navigating a store. The insight that ultimately drove adoption was adding an item-location feature that made shopping faster and easier—not more complex.
The Lesson
Minimize friction, not maximize features. Your customers want to shop online, pick up in-store, check inventory before they drive over, and return items easily. They don't want a complicated app or loyalty program.
What this means for independent retailers:
Your Shopify store should make it easier for customers to shop with you—not add complexity. Focus on the basics: accurate inventory, easy pickup, simple returns.
Action Steps:
- Enable "buy online, pick up in store" (BOPIS) on your Shopify store
- Show real-time inventory availability on product pages
- Make returns easy (in-store or online)
- Don't force customers into a loyalty app—meet them where they are (email, SMS, social)
Bonus Insight: Your Suppliers Want to Invest in You
If You Can Prove ROI
While this wasn't explicitly discussed in keynotes, conversations with retail technology vendors revealed a massive opportunity for independent retailers: suppliers are increasing trade marketing and co-op budgets, but they want data-driven proof of ROI.
Retailers who can show suppliers exactly how their campaigns performed (impressions, clicks, conversions, in-store traffic) are winning bigger budgets. Those who can't are getting left behind.
What this means for independent retailers:
Your Shopify store + Google Ads + Meta campaigns generate data that big-box retailers can't match: local, targeted, measurable results. This is your leverage to grow your share of supplier marketing budgets.
Action Steps:
- Track campaign performance by supplier/brand (use UTM parameters and Shopify analytics)
- Create simple reports showing suppliers their ROI (impressions, clicks, sales, foot traffic)
- Pitch suppliers on co-op campaigns with measurable results
- Use this data to negotiate better terms and bigger budgets
The Bottom Line
The biggest themes from NRF 2026 weren't about technology for technology's sake. They were about using modern tools to amplify what independent retailers have always done best: build relationships, provide expert guidance, and create experiences that make customers want to come back.
As an independent retailer competing with category killers, you have advantages they don't:
✓ Local expertise — You know your community better than any corporate buyer
✓ Personal service — Your team can provide guidance that no chatbot can match
✓ Agility — You can test new approaches without corporate bureaucracy
✓ Community trust — You're a local business, not a faceless corporation
The question isn't whether you can compete with Dick's, Best Buy, or Sephora. The question is: Are you using digital tools to amplify your physical store's strengths? Because the retailers winning in 2026 are the ones who understand that online and offline aren't competitors—they're partners.
.png)
